Concert Review Archive


Ian Anderson

Friday, 2nd May 2014
Philharmonic Hall, Liverpool, the UK

Article By Elwyn (Owen) Davies and photos By Martin Webb

I concluded my recent DPRP review of Homo Erraticus by stating optimistically ‘I hope that Homo Erraticus does not falter or fall, weighed down by the expectations of past achievements, unnoticed into the pit of indifference’. I looked forward expectantly to see how Homo Erraticus might be transferred to a live setting as it was initially created with live performances in mind. The piece was refined in the studio as an entity to grow and develop further on the stage. Now that it was ready to take the step to a fully fledged live performance, I was confident that it would not disappoint, and, as Bostock might have said, 'I really did not think that I should sit this one out'.

I had heard an audio of the opening night of the tour in Brighton. Frankly, it was not great - in fact it was quite poor. I feared that I was going to witness a further decline in the live performance of the aging enigmatic, and talented Ian Anderson. I even seriously contemplated that maybe after all I should indeed ‘sit this one out’

In interviews Anderson had promised a theatrical live show and interpretation of Homo Erraticus. In this respect the performance did not disappoint. The show began with a tongue in cheek filmed introduction, featuring members of the band, to set the concept. This was soon followed by an enjoyably powerful rendition of the opening track of the album. Any misgivings about the quality of the performance were soon dispelled. The sound was full and rich, the visual backdrop and presentation superbly complementing the unfolding concept of the album. Andersons ailing vocals were once more supplemented sensitively by the warm tones of Ryan O’Donnell. Perhaps most satisfyingly though, the band were energised and seemed to be having a lot of fun!

Ian Anderson

Homo Erraticus has been Anderson’s most commercially successful release for many years. In this context, unfettered by the past achievements of Jethro Tull, the ensemble were adeptly able to bring Anderson’s latest music to life. The tightness and quality of the player’s performance was outstanding. This ensured that the live interpretation of Homo Erraticus exploded rather than crawled out of any perceived pit of indifference that onlookers might have had. Anderson’s obvious conviction in his latest music was apparent in the energy and vitality in which he moved his 66 year old frame around the stage. Equally evident was the rest of the player’s confidence in the nature of the material and satisfaction in being a part of its initial creation and now, replication in a live show. No doubt, by the end of Cold Dead Reckoning any doubters had probably been won over. Immersed in the whole theatrical experience, I know I had. Homo Erraticus, initially conceived as a blind date with the muse, had evolved and was, I felt, much more fulfilling and meaningful in a live setting. The music had the punch and vibrancy that the disappointing production of the release had lacked. The audience reacted and responded accordingly, marking the end of the first set with genuine applause, warmth and enthusiasm.

Ian Anderson

The second half of the concert featuring the best of Jethro Tull was greeted with rapture as David Goodier’s bass began Living In the Past. Whilst the first half of the show was good, the second half raised the bar further. Played in mostly chronological order, a veritable juke box of arguably some of Tull’s best tunes from their eclectic back catalogue emerged. Musically and visually the band was able to capture and interpret the scale and grandeur of Tull’s music. Within a set of many highlights I particularly enjoyed the interpretations given to Teacher, With You There To Help Me, Critique Oblique, Too Old To Rock and Roll and My God.

Florian Opahle added many fine individual enhancements to the original guitar parts. His playing never failed to entertain or impress. The way in which his solo in Aqualung was imaginatively constructed was excellent. It was refreshingly different, had great variety and depth but was also respectful to Martin Barre’s outstanding original part.

Ian Anderson

The limitations and occasional rasping element of Anderson’s vocals were disguised adequately throughout the show. When notes were occasionally failed this did not have a particularly adverse effect on the performance at Liverpool which was the fourth date of the tour. Whether what is left of his voice is able to withstand the rigours of an extensive tour is another matter though. Regardless, Ryan O ‘Donnell should be commended for his supporting role. When necessary, as in Songs From The Wood, John O ‘Hara and David Goodier also provided much needed vocal support

It was refreshing to hear Critique Oblique from A Passion Play and it reminded me of the depth, power and sheer malevolence of that album. Although Anderson appeared eager to downplay this extract from the album, asserting that he felt maybe he “went a bit too far”. To me though, this stood out as testament to a particular side and spirit of his genius which I felt was largely ignored by the rest of this set, particularly due to the absence of Thick As A Brick. How about a one off anniversary performance or tour of “A Passion Play”, Ian? Now that is a show I really would not contemplate sitting out.

Heavy Metals
Enter The Uninvited
Puer Ferox Adventus
Meliora Sequamur
The Turnpike Inn
The Engineer
The Pax Britannica
Tripudium Ad Bellum
After These Wars
New Blood, Old Veins
In For A Pound
The Browning of the Green
Per Errationes Ad Astra
Cold Dead Reckoning

Sweet Dream
With You There to Help Me
Passion Play
Songs From The Wood
Farm On The Freeway
My God
Locomotive Breath

Ian Anderson's official Website

DPRP's Review of "Homo Erraticus"

Philharmonic Hall


© 1996 - 2019 : Dutch Progressive Rock Page